Jill died in 1975. She was 10 years old. I was away when she died, across the country at a spiritual retreat. “How could You,” I cried! “How could You take her while I am away, striving to do Your will, striving to come to know You better, how could You take my daughter from me?!! “
Jill had epilepsy. She had seizures that would last from a few minutes to several hours in a raging nightmare of non-stop seizures called status epilepticus. She had her first seizure when she was a year and a half, chasing her new puppy across the back yard. Suddenly she fell forward with a force that looked as though she had been thrown. By the time of her death she had been to every doctor and hospital in the surrounding area. There was no help for her; only an increase of medications that made her listless and unable to walk, looking more like a drunk on a sidewalk than an 8 or 9 year old child.
And yet... “How could You?”
What faith I had was sorely tested. Gradually over the years I began to find I could almost accept her death. There was never a time that the thought of her would not bring me close to tears or at times be ravaged by the sudden memory, clear and golden, of her beautiful face and shiny bright blue eyes. And then the struggle to regain any sense of faith or meaning would ensue. But gradually, I began to find a semblance of faith and trust returning. But there was always that final place, that hidden center that would shrink back when touched... could I ever really, fully trust Him again?
And then in my sixties I too began to have seizures. First only moments of disorientation but gradually full seizures during the night, which my husband witnessed but I only knew by my swollen tongue or bruised lip when I awoke. For nearly five years I watched as this illness progressed aware that medical science had nothing further to offer me than it had offered my daughter but eventually, through the grace of Allah and deep tawba, these seizures stopped. And it was then that something began to open.
In prayer one morning I began thinking about this healing and feeling such deep gratitude. In particular I remembered thinking because these seizures had only happened at night, I had been able to keep driving. If these had been daytime seizures I would have had to stop driving, a particular trial since my husband and I had just moved to a farm out in the country, 30 miles from the nearest town. And as I thought about this grace, I began thinking about Jill. She would never have been able to drive or to have a child—how could she even give a child a bath if at any moment she could be rendered unconscious leaving the child to drown? Jill’s life would have continued to be a series of woundings, both emotional and physical as she struggled with this debilitating illness. And slowly I became aware that her death was a mercy for her, a gift of release from this suffering and in that dawning awareness I saw too that her death was also a mercy for me. Who suffers more than a parent for their child?
Later, someone asked, “If this was a mercy, then why did she have epilepsy in the first place?” My only response is that God knows who I am and who He created me to be and He knew that this trial was the only way I could come to love and trust Him from the deepest level of my soul. And so I am grateful for His love and mercy that surrounds me and fills me and keeps us both safe.